YouTube Sued Over Animal Abuse Videos, Accused of Not Enforcing Ban


But Nina Jackel, founder of Lady Freethinker, mentioned in an interview that there was no grey space with many of the animal abuse movies, and that an organization of YouTube’s dimension and sources ought to have the ability to determine and take away these clear violations.

Ivy Choi, a YouTube spokeswoman, mentioned the corporate had expanded its coverage on animal abuse movies this 12 months. Since then, she mentioned, it has eliminated a whole bunch of hundreds of movies and terminated hundreds of channels for violations. She cautioned that it took time to extend enforcement.

“We agree that content depicting violence or abuse toward animals has no place on YouTube,” Ms. Choi mentioned in an announcement. Of 10 animal movies that The New York Times shared with YouTube, the corporate eliminated 9 for violating its violent or graphic content material coverage. The one which was not eliminated reveals a dwell rabbit being fed to a python. YouTube declined to elucidate why this video didn’t violate its tips.

Through its legal professionals, Lady Freethinker additionally despatched a letter to the Justice Department on Monday, accusing YouTube of aiding and abetting the violation of “animal crushing” legislation. Created in 1999 and amended in 2010 and 2019, the federal legislation prohibits making or distributing movies wherein animals are “purposely crushed, burned, drowned, suffocated, impaled or otherwise subjected to serious bodily injury.”

The legislation permits exceptions for movies wherein animals could also be harmed in slaughter for meals, authorized searching, the safety of individuals or property, medical analysis and euthanasia.

In the grievance and letter, the animal rights group mentioned YouTube was taking advantage of animal abuse as a result of some of the movies ran commercials. For instance, a video of a pet desperately attempting to flee the grasp of a python was preceded by a business for Vrbo, the holiday rental unit of Expedia Group.

Many of the feedback on the video are additionally troubling. Under one video wherein a child monkey is manhandled whereas it screams in terror, one commentator referred to as it a “thrill.” Under the identical video, one other particular person wrote that the creator ought to break the monkey’s arms to instill “some severe discipline.”